We go carb-free most of the year, but when Thanksgiving comes around, all bets are off. As a kid, my order at Capriotti’s was always the Bobbie: turkey, cranberry, stuffing, and mayo piled into one of their huge sub rolls, and there is no better Thanksgiving leftover sandwich. Once a year, with a mountain of leftover turkey in the fridge, I make the exception, and this is exactly what I make.

Capriotti’s turned 50 this year, and the Bobbie has been on the menu since the first shop opened in 1976, named for the founders’ Aunt Bobbie, who was famous in the family for her day-after-Thanksgiving leftover sandwiches. Want your turkey cold and spoonable instead? Our Turkey Salad folds cranberries and pecans into a rosemary aioli. This sub keeps every Thanksgiving component whole and stacks them.

🔪 Ingredients for a Copycat Bobbie Sub
- Soft sub rolls, about 8 inches: soft, not crusty. A soft roll squeezes down around the fillings when you press the sub closed, and a hard artisan crust pushes everything out the back end.
- Leftover roast turkey: white and dark meat mixed, pulled into bite-size pieces. The dark meat keeps every bite juicy. Still on the bone? Here’s how to carve a turkey without shredding the breast. Leftover smoked turkey works too.
- Leftover stuffing, cold from the fridge: chilled stuffing holds its shape when you pile it on. Any bread stuffing works, including our Apple Sausage Stuffing.
- Mayo: a thick layer, about 3 tablespoons per roll. It’s the richness in every bite and the barrier that keeps the bread from going soggy.
- Whole-berry cranberry sauce: use whatever leftovers you have.
- Kosher salt and black pepper
📝 How to Make a Thanksgiving Leftover Sandwich
- Split the rolls, leaving a hinge. Spread a thick layer of mayo on both cut faces, edge to edge, about 3 tablespoons per roll, until no bare bread shows.
- Layer the turkey on the bottom and season it with salt and pepper. Then spoon the cranberry sauce over the top of the turkey.
- Finally, pile on the stuffing.
- Close the sub and press firmly until the fillings settle and the roll stays shut on its own. Cut in half with a serrated knife.

🔄 Substitutions
- Jellied cranberry sauce for whole-berry: spreads smoother and loses the berry texture. Stir it with a fork first so it spoons evenly over the turkey.
- Leftover roast chicken for the turkey: same amount, same layer, white and dark mixed.
- Hoagie or soft Italian rolls for sub rolls: any soft, long roll works. Skip baguettes and crusty bread, which fight you on every bite.
- Sage mayo for plain mayo: the classic stays plain, but for a herby upgrade, stir minced fresh sage and a squeeze of lemon into the mayo, or use our Sage Aioli.
💡 Meat Nerd Tips
- Mayo on both faces, and thick. About 3 tablespoons per roll, all the way to the crust, top and bottom. Any bare spot is where turkey juice and cranberry soak straight into the bread.
- Salt the cold turkey. Leftover turkey straight from the fridge tastes flatter than it did hot off the carving board. Salt and pepper right on the turkey, before the cranberry goes on, brings it back.
- Stuffing goes on last. Piled on top, it sits against the mayo on the top half of the roll, and the cranberry stays tucked between the turkey and the stuffing instead of hitting bread.
- Press it hard before you cut. Leaning on the closed sub settles the fillings and glues the layers to the mayo, so the halves cut clean and stay together.

🍽️ What to Serve with a Thanksgiving Leftover Sandwich
- Turkey carcass soup: soup and a sandwich from the same bird. Simmer the frame into our Turkey Carcass Soup and serve it hot next to the cold sub.
- Creamy turkey soup: our Hatch Chili Creamy Turkey Soup brings a little green chile heat against the sweet cranberry.
- Dill pickles and kettle chips: sour and salty crunch cuts through all that mayo.
- A sharp green salad: a mustardy vinaigrette gives the table something bright after two days of rich food.
🧊 Leftovers and Storage
- Built subs: best within a few hours. Wrapped tight and refrigerated, they hold until the next day.
- The leftovers themselves: use turkey, stuffing and cranberry within 3 to 4 days of Thanksgiving.
- Freezer: skip it for built subs. Mayo separates when it thaws.
- Still more turkey? Work through our leftover turkey recipes or head back to the complete guide to Thanksgiving turkey to plan next year’s bird.
Bobbie-Style Turkey, Cranberry and Stuffing Sub

Recommended Equipment
- Serrated knife
Ingredients
- 4 soft sub rolls about 8 inches
- 1 to 1 1/4 lb leftover roast turkey pulled into bite-size pieces, white and dark mixed
- 3 cups leftover stuffing cold from the fridge
- 3/4 to 1 cup mayo a thick layer, about 3 tbsp per roll
- 1 cup whole-berry cranberry sauce
- Kosher salt and black pepper
Instructions
Mayo the Rolls
- Split the rolls, leaving a hinge. Spread a thick layer of mayo on both cut faces, edge to edge.
Turkey and Cranberry
- Layer the turkey on the bottom and season it with salt and pepper. Then spoon the cranberry sauce over top.
Stuffing
- Finally, pile on the stuffing.
Close and Cut
- Close the sub, press firmly, and cut in half.
Notes
- Sage mayo upgrade: stir 1 tbsp finely minced fresh sage and 1 tsp lemon juice into 1/2 cup mayo. Rest 30 minutes before using. Or use our Sage Aioli.
- Mayo on both faces, edge to edge, is what keeps the sub from going soggy.
- Use leftovers within 3 to 4 days of Thanksgiving. Do not freeze built subs; mayo separates when it thaws.
Save this Recipe
Nutrition
Bookmark this recipe now!
Quick Summary
This Thanksgiving leftover sandwich stacks cold turkey, cranberry sauce and stuffing on a soft sub roll with a thick layer of mayo on both faces, the way the Capriotti’s Bobbie does it. Season the turkey, spoon the cranberry right over it, and pile the stuffing on last before you press it shut.
❓ FAQs
The Bobbie is turkey, cranberry sauce, stuffing and mayo on a sub roll. Capriotti’s has served it since opening in 1976 and named it for an aunt who made it from her holiday leftovers.
Spread a thick layer of mayo on both cut faces of the roll, edge to edge, so no bare bread touches the fillings. Spoon the cranberry onto the turkey instead of the bread, pile the stuffing on last, and press the sub firmly closed.
This one is built cold, straight from the fridge, and that is how we like it best. The mayo stays thick and the stuffing holds its shape instead of going mushy.
Yes. Jellied cranberry spreads smoother and has no berry texture. Stir it with a fork first so it spoons evenly over the turkey.
Refrigerated leftover turkey is good for 3 to 4 days after Thanksgiving. The same window applies to the stuffing and cranberry sauce going into this sub.














