The Forgotten Cuts of Meat Butchers Wish You’d Try

The first hanger steak I ever cooked came home wrapped in butcher paper with a warning from the guy behind the counter: do not overcook it. I seared it in cast iron, sliced it thin against the grain, and stopped defaulting to ribeye that night. That is the quiet truth of the meat case. The cuts nobody asks for are the ones butchers carry home.

You do not need a bigger budget to eat better beef. You need to know what to ask for by name. These are the cuts worth requesting, and exactly how to cook each one so it earns a permanent spot in your rotation.

Hanger Steak

Hanger steak hangs off the diaphragm, one per animal, and for decades butchers kept it for themselves. The old nickname, butcher’s steak, was not marketing. It was a confession.

The grain is loose and the flavor runs deep, closer to skirt than strip. Cook it hot and fast: a hard sear, 3 to 4 minutes per side, pulled at 125 degrees F on a Thermapen for medium rare. Rest it 10 minutes, then slice thin against the grain. Skip that last step and even a flawless cook chews like a tire. Start with our grilled hanger steak and you will understand why butchers stayed quiet about it for a century.

Tri-Tip

Tri-tip is a triangular muscle off the bottom sirloin that California figured out generations ago. Santa Maria pitmasters built an entire tradition on it: salt, pepper, garlic, and red oak smoke. The rest of the country is still catching up.

Treat it like a small roast, not a steak. Smoke it low around 225 degrees F, then sear it hard at the end to finish around 130 for medium rare. Here is the part everyone misses: the grain changes direction partway through the cut. Slice each section separately, always across the grain. Our smoked tri-tip walks you through the whole cook, slicing included.

Flat Iron

The flat iron comes off the shoulder, cut from the top blade with the tough seam of connective tissue removed. What remains is one of the most tender cuts on the steer, with better marbling than a filet and far more flavor to show for it.

Its even thickness and flat surface mean full contact with a hot pan, which means crust from edge to edge. Season it, sear it, pull it at 125, and rest it. That is the whole job. How to cook flat iron steak covers both the pan and the grill.

Teres Major

Ask for teres major and watch your butcher’s eyebrows go up. This small shoulder muscle is sometimes called the petite tender because its texture runs close to filet mignon. Most shops grind it into chuck because nobody requests it by name.

It is about the size of a pork tenderloin and cooks in minutes. Sear it whole in butter, roll it every couple of minutes for even color, pull it at 125 degrees F, and slice it into medallions. Our garlic butter basted teres major is the blueprint.

Oxtail

Oxtail is the opposite play: no sear-and-serve, all patience. The tail is loaded with collagen that melts into gelatin over a long braise, which is why oxtail broth coats your lips like nothing else in the butcher case.

Brown the pieces hard first. Then braise or slow cook them for 3 to 4 hours, until the meat slumps off the bone. Our slow cooker oxtail soup does the heavy lifting while you get on with your day.

How to Order at the Counter

Walk up and ask what is underrated this week. Butchers light up at that question. If hanger or teres major is not in the case, most shops will cut it for you with a day of notice. Tell them how you plan to cook it and let them steer you. While you are there, ask about bavette, Denver steak, and beef shank. Same story: big flavor, low demand.

Buying this way also honors the whole animal. Every muscle got raised on the same feed and the same time. Cooking more of them is the least wasteful, most respectful way to eat meat.

The ribeye will still be there next week. Order the cut nobody else wants and cook it like you mean it.

Hungry for more? Subscribe to our newsletter and become part of the world’s best meat community! From grilling tips to smoky secrets, we send you the best recipes, guides, and expert advice to master every cut.